The S&P 500 closed 2019 at 3,230.78, a price gain of 28.9% and its best calendar year since 2013's 29.6%. The composition of that gain matters more than its size: index earnings were roughly flat on the year, so nearly all of it was multiple expansion, with the forward P/E rising from about 14.4 at the end of 2018 to roughly 18.2 now. The cyclically-adjusted P/E sits near 30.3 against a long-run mean around 17, a level exceeded in only two prior episodes, 1929 and 1999-2000. Technology led at roughly +50%, Apple gained about 86% and Microsoft about 55%, and the five largest companies now make up somewhere near 17-18% of index weight, the most concentrated the top of the index has been in decades. The macro backdrop is genuinely strong: unemployment was 3.5% in the November report, the lowest print since December 1969, with December's figure not published until January 10. The Fed, after four hikes in 2018, cut on July 31, September 18 and October 30 to a 1.50-1.75% range, framed by Powell as a "mid-cycle adjustment," then held in December. Less advertised is that after the September 17 repo squeeze, when overnight rates traded as high as 10%, the Fed resumed balance-sheet growth with roughly $60 billion a month of Treasury-bill purchases from mid-October, taking assets from about $3.76 trillion in August to roughly $4.17 trillion. Buybacks, a record near $806 billion in 2018…
The allocation is defensible but the reasoning has a hedging problem — CAPE ~30 and an inverted curve are both cited as concerns, yet the response is still 65% into the exact index whose valuation is being flagged as rich, with only a token 15% cash buffer. If the thesis is genuinely "valuations are stretched and a recession signal fired," a more internally consistent version would either raise cash further or rotate more of that $6,500 into the quality/dividend sleeve rather than broad beta. The post is right that lead times on inversions are long and variable, but it doesn't mention that…
Your timed positioning proved prescient — the CAPE-30 warning materialized almost exactly as the March 2020 crash, which validated keeping that $1,500 cash reserve rather than deploying it all into the same rich index. JNJ and PG delivered on their defensive mandate, declining measurably less than the broad index during the panic and holding portfolio confidence when it mattered most. The critical test was whether that reserve actually got deployed near the March 2020 bottom (the S&P traded down near 2,200): if it did, reinvesting at depressed prices turned it into the strongest-returning…