The S&P 500 closed 2014 at 2,058.90, up 11.4% on price and 13.7% with dividends, against the March 9, 2009 closing low of 676.53. Calling that six straight up years is only true on a total-return basis; 2011 was effectively flat on price, 1,257.60 versus 1,257.64, and positive only because of dividends. Valuation is elevated without being extreme: forward P/E near 16.5, trailing about 18.6, and a cyclically-adjusted P/E around 26.5 against a long-run mean near 16.5. The labor market is improving without overheating: unemployment was 5.8% in the November report against the October 2009 peak of 10.0%, with December's figure not due until January 9; U-6 is still 11.4% and average hourly earnings are up only about 1.7% year over year, which is why nobody expects the Fed to move aggressively. November payrolls came in at 321,000, the strongest month since early 2012, and third-quarter GDP was revised on December 23 to a 5.0% annualized rate, the best since 2003. The Fed ended QE3 on October 29 and has held the funds rate at 0-0.25% since December 16, 2008; the December 17 statement replaced "considerable time" with "can be patient," which most read as no hike before mid-2015. Yet the 10-year Treasury ends the year at 2.17%, down from 3.03% twelve months ago, and the German 10-year sits near 0.54% with euro-area inflation at 0.3% in November. The bond market is plainly not pricing a…
Reasonable and appropriately granular — the oil-crash-as-consumer-tailwind logic is sound and the AAPL/HD picks both fit the stated macro thesis rather than being generic mega-cap picks. The weak point is the total avoidance of energy: by Dec 2014 a lot of the crude repricing was already in the price, and this allocation ends up making a fairly confident directional bet — that oil stays low and OPEC doesn't reverse course — dressed up as risk avoidance rather than sized as the directional call it actually is. It also doesn't address rate-hike-cycle risk to HD specifically, which is a…
The cash call is the part I'd defend loudest: WTI didn't stabilize near $53, it kept sliding to roughly $26 by February 2016, and energy went on to be the S&P's worst sector for most of the following five years — so the caution was vindicated, even though the post never defined a re-entry trigger and the sleeve quietly became a permanent drag, since the Fed didn't leave the zero bound until December 2015 and cash paid essentially nothing until 2023. The SPY core was the easy win: the index closed 2014 near 2,059 and has since roughly tripled in price, more with dividends reinvested. AAPL at…