Why gold is different
Most commodities are valued for what they are used up in: oil is burned, wheat is eaten, copper is wired into buildings. Gold is different. Very little of it is consumed. Most of the gold ever mined still exists, as jewellery, bars, coins and central bank reserves. Its price is driven much less by industrial use and much more by people's desire to hold it.
That is why gold is often described as a store of value: an asset people hold to preserve wealth over time, rather than to consume or to earn income from.
The case made for gold
The World Gold Council, an industry body funded by gold producers (worth keeping in mind), argues in its 2026 report that gold has a role as a long-term strategic holding in a diversified portfolio. Its main points:
- Diversification: gold has often moved differently from shares and bonds.
- No credit risk: gold is nobody's liability. A bond can default and a bank can fail; a gold bar cannot.
- Liquidity: gold is traded in large volumes worldwide.
- Safe-haven demand: investors have often turned to gold during periods of economic or political uncertainty.
These are reasonable arguments, and the Council itself adds the standard caveats that diversification does not guarantee returns and past performance is not indicative of future results.
The case against, or at least for caution
- No income. Gold pays no interest or dividends. Its only return is a price change, and storing it costs money.
- Long, painful flat or falling periods. Gold has gone through multi-year periods of falling or flat prices in real terms. Holding it requires the same patience as any volatile asset.
- Valuation is hard. With no cash flows, there is no clear way to say what gold "should" be worth. Claude Erb and Campbell Harvey's research "The Golden Dilemma" found that when gold's inflation-adjusted price had been above its historical average, subsequent real returns had tended to be below average, which they interpreted as a sign of mean reversion. They also noted that rising demand from emerging-market central banks and investors could push prices further, hence the "dilemma".
- The inflation-hedge claim is weaker than often stated. The same research concluded that gold may be a good inflation hedge over very long periods (centuries) but an unreliable one over horizons up to about 20 years, which are the horizons that matter to most people (see: The dollar, inflation and hedge claims examined).
What moves the gold price
No single factor explains gold, but several are widely discussed:
- Real interest rates. Because gold pays nothing, the opportunity cost of holding it rises when safe investments pay a good return after inflation, and falls when they do not. This is one reason gold is sensitive to central bank policy (see: Interest rates, inflation, central banks and currencies, in Markets explanation).
- The US dollar. Gold is priced in dollars globally. The BIS notes that commodities are generally invoiced in dollars, so a stronger dollar raises their cost in other currencies, which can weigh on demand.
- Fear and uncertainty. Crises, wars and financial stress can increase safe-haven buying.
- Central bank buying and selling. Central banks are major holders and their decisions can shift demand significantly.
- Jewellery and investment demand in large consumer markets, which can be sensitive to price and local incomes.
Silver: half precious metal, half industrial metal
Silver is also held as a store of value, in coins, bars and funds, but unlike gold a large part of its demand comes from industry: electronics, electrical components, solar panels and other uses. That gives silver a split personality:
- It often moves in the same direction as gold in periods of monetary or safe-haven demand.
- It is also affected by the economic cycle, because industrial demand rises and falls with manufacturing.
- It has typically been more volatile than gold: a smaller market with both investment and industrial swings.
Silver's lower price per ounce makes it feel more accessible, but as with crypto tokens, a lower unit price says nothing about value or expected return (see: Coins, tokens, market cap and supply, in Crypto for beginners). Physical silver also has higher storage bulk and often larger dealer premiums relative to its value.
Ways to hold precious metals
Briefly (covered in detail in: ETFs, ETCs, ETNs and physical holdings compared):
- Coins and bars: direct ownership, with dealer spreads, storage and insurance costs.
- Physically backed funds or ETCs: track the spot price closely minus an annual fee; justETF notes that physically backed precious-metal ETCs hold metal with a trustee.
- Mining company shares: a different investment, with company risks on top (see: Producer stocks vs the commodity, and the real costs and risks).
Worked example: what "store of value" does and does not mean (illustrative numbers)
Imagine an investor who keeps 10% of a 100,000 portfolio in gold and, to keep the arithmetic simple, the other 90% in shares. In a year when shares fall 25% and gold rises 10%, the portfolio falls 21.5% (a 22,500 loss on shares, partly offset by a 1,000 gain on gold) instead of the 25% it would have lost in shares alone. In a year when shares rise 20% and gold falls 10%, the gold slice drags on returns. Gold's possible value in a portfolio comes from behaving differently, which means it will sometimes be the worst performer. There is no guarantee it rises in any particular crisis.
Key takeaways
- Gold is valued mainly for being held, not consumed; its demand is driven by investment, jewellery and central banks.
- Arguments for: diversification, no credit risk, liquidity, safe-haven demand.
- Arguments against: no income, long flat periods, hard to value, weaker short-horizon inflation hedging than often claimed.
- Real interest rates, the dollar, fear and central bank activity all influence the gold price.
- Silver mixes store-of-value and industrial demand and has typically been more volatile than gold.
Common mistakes
Treating gold as a guaranteed crisis winner, ignoring storage and premium costs on physical metal, buying silver because it "looks cheap" per ounce, and taking industry-funded research as the whole story.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Precious metal prices can fall significantly and for long periods.
Test yourself
- Why do rising real interest rates tend to be a headwind for gold?
Answer: Gold pays no income, so when safe assets pay more after inflation, the opportunity cost of holding gold rises.
- What did Erb and Harvey conclude about gold as an inflation hedge?
Answer: It may hedge inflation over centuries but is unreliable over horizons up to about 20 years.
- Why does silver often swing more than gold?
Answer: It is a smaller market with significant industrial demand, so it reacts to the economic cycle as well as to investment demand.
Educational only, not financial advice.